Feedback Requested: Reviews
New Reply
If you were logged in you would gain 3 XP for posting a reply.
Support Nibbits by linking to us:
Your
WarCraft 3 Resource
Feedback Requested: Reviews
More from Nibbits: WarCraft 3 Maps | StarCraft Maps | StarCraft 2 Maps | Gamer Configs
Contact | Advertising | About | Pending Changes from Users | Become an Affiliate | Database Statistics | Terms of Use | Twitter | API Documentation
I'd like to see what you all think of reviews so far. I think they're off to a good start.
Im hoping to have Author's Response implemented very soon, with the plan to have it shown on the same page as a review. It would also show a snippet of it within the review summary on the list of reviews.
I think that they are a really good idea. I do however, think that 60 experience is a little much.
I think that they are good except that I can't review yet. And 60 xp is a little much, maybe 25ish?
I think it's great. Can't wait for the author response.
i think 60 exp is too few.. 1k perhaps? lol
I think the rating should appear on the review page itself, and not just on the front page of nibbits.
If you look over to the far right it gives stars (which is the same as giving the good, average, needs improvement, etc.)
it's a great idea :)
If it's that much why is there only 3 reviews yet?.. Think it's alright.
ya, agreed!
Well 5 warcraft maps have reviews, 4 by the same person (and the other by me ^_^)
60 exp
x4 reviews
__
240 exp.
Yeah, I guess that isn't that bad.
Are starcraft maps supposed to be reviewable? Because if they are, they aren't.
*sigh* yes they are. See this:
Still can't figure it out? Tell me the map name and I will find it for you.
I promise I will fix that soon ;)
I'm also going to tweak the XP so it's a range. I believe we'll do each review from 25-60 XP based on quality, and length. It will be left up to the moderator (which is me, at the moment) to decide how much XP to award.
A link on the review section of the home page to all the reviews that have been approved.
Wish granted for dedicated review page :)
I just pushed live some more changes to reviews. It includes an Originality rating, and comments for each rating.
Map projects that are ranked top ten to be featured on the home page.!
Thought this was a main feature at one point?
There is a maps box below featured map on the homepage which by default shows popular maps (top 10).
Well I see maps on that list that are ranked below 10? Seems confusing that it is a popular map but it has a whack rank. See at one point my map Lazerus TD was ranked 5th but the map was not on that list? Are you seeing where I am going with this.
You're right there's definitely a bug. I think it's just a bug with displaying the maps rank, as it seems to be good on the browse pages (which show projects):
http://wc3.nibbits.com/maps/browse/?sort=rank&order=desc
Could you make that the link to view more maps? As of now this view more maps link only shows 10 maps.